Redefining Recruitment Success: Why Finding the 'Best Candidate' Isn't Everything

Posted on 6th October 2023 by Phil Brown

When it comes to hiring and promoting employees, the pressure to find the 'best candidate' can be overwhelming. But what if we start to think differently about success? In this article, we will explore why it's important to reframe our expectations of success and why finding the 'best candidate' is not necessarily the only path to a successful outcome.

Why the search for the 'best candidate' can Be detrimental

When organisations place all their focus on finding the 'best candidate', they can unintentionally limit their pool of talent and hinder the growth of their teams. This search for perfection often results in overlooking individuals who may have the potential to excel in the role and contribute in unique ways.

The quest for the 'best candidate' also puts immense pressure on both the hiring team and the applicants. The hiring team may become too fixated on checking off every box on their ideal candidate checklist, while the applicants may feel overwhelmed trying to fit into a mold that may not accurately represent their capabilities. This perfectionist mindset can lead to missed opportunities and a lack of diversity within the organisation.

Moreover, focusing solely on finding the 'best candidate' can be detrimental to the development and growth of existing employees. By constantly seeking external talent, organizations may overlook the potential of their current team members and miss out on the opportunity to invest in their professional growth and advancement.

Instead of fixating on the 'best candidate', organisations should shift their focus to identifying individuals with potential, passion, and a willingness to learn. By nurturing and developing these employees, organizations can create a more diverse and inclusive environment that allows for innovation and growth.

In the next section, we will delve deeper into the dangers of perfectionism in the hiring process and explore the benefits of focusing on potential over experience. Stay tuned!

The dangers of perfectionism in hiring

In the quest to find the 'best candidate', organisations often fall into the trap of perfectionism, which can be detrimental to their hiring process. When perfection becomes the sole focus, it creates an unrealistic expectation that the perfect candidate exists. This mindset can result in rejecting qualified individuals who may not meet every single criteria but possess valuable skills and potential.

Perfectionism also leads to a lack of diversity within teams. When organisations are fixated on finding candidates who fit a predetermined mould, they limit the opportunity to bring in different perspectives and experiences. This narrow-minded approach stifles innovation and creativity, preventing organizations from reaching their full potential.

Furthermore, the pressure to be perfect in the hiring process can lead to a slow and inefficient process. The endless pursuit of the ideal candidate can delay decision-making, resulting in missed opportunities to fill positions and move the organization forward.

By understanding the dangers of perfectionism in hiring, organisations can shift their mindset and embrace a more inclusive approach. They can focus on recognising potential, passion, and a willingness to learn, rather than just a checklist of qualifications. In doing so, they open themselves up to a world of possibilities and allow for growth and innovation within their teams.

The benefits of focusing on potential over experience

When it comes to hiring and promoting employees, many organisations tend to prioritise experience over potential. However, there are numerous benefits to focusing on potential rather than just years of experience.

One of the key advantages of looking at potential is the ability to identify individuals who may not have extensive experience but possess a hunger to learn and grow. These individuals bring fresh perspectives and a willingness to take on new challenges, which can greatly benefit the organization in terms of innovation and adaptability.

Additionally, focusing on potential allows organisations to tap into a diverse talent pool. By not solely relying on a rigid set of qualifications, companies can consider candidates from different backgrounds and experiences. This promotes diversity and inclusion, leading to a more dynamic and well-rounded team.

Furthermore, prioritising potential over experience encourages professional development within the organisation. By giving individuals opportunities to learn and expand their skills, organisations can foster loyalty and create a culture of continuous growth.

Ultimately, by focusing on potential, organisations open themselves up to a wider range of possibilities and create an environment where individuals can thrive and reach their full potential.

How to evaluate candidates effectively

To evaluate candidates effectively, it's important to move beyond just looking at their qualifications and experience. While these factors are important, they don't tell the full story of a candidate's potential and fit within your organization. Here are a few key strategies to consider when evaluating candidates:

  1. Focus on strengths: Instead of solely looking at a candidate's weaknesses or areas for improvement, identify their strengths and how those strengths align with the requirements of the role. This will help you gauge their potential to excel and contribute to your team.
  2. Assess cultural fit: It's crucial to consider how a candidate will fit into your organisation's culture. Look for candidates who align with your values, demonstrate strong communication and collaboration skills, and have a positive attitude.
  3. Use behavioural interview questions: These questions allow you to delve deeper into a candidate's past experiences and how they have handled various situations. This can provide valuable insights into their problem-solving skills, adaptability, and ability to work well under pressure.
  4. Consider their potential for growth: Look for candidates who show a willingness to learn, take on new challenges, and adapt to changing circumstances. Assess their potential for growth and how they can contribute to the long-term success of your organisation.

By using these strategies, you can evaluate candidates more effectively and make informed decisions based on their potential rather than just their qualifications and experience. This will help you find individuals who can bring fresh perspectives, contribute to a diverse and inclusive team, and drive innovation within your organisation.

Embracing diversity and inclusion in hiring practices

In today's rapidly evolving world, it's more important than ever for organisations to embrace diversity and inclusion in their hiring practices. By seeking out candidates from a wide range of backgrounds and experiences, companies can foster a culture of innovation, creativity, and adaptability.

Embracing diversity means acknowledging and appreciating the unique perspectives, talents, and strengths that individuals from different backgrounds bring to the table. By creating a diverse team, organisations can benefit from a variety of viewpoints, problem-solving approaches, and ideas. This leads to better decision-making and the ability to navigate complex challenges with ease.

Inclusion, on the other hand, is about ensuring that all employees feel valued, respected, and empowered to contribute their best work. It means creating an environment where everyone has an equal opportunity to thrive and grow. When employees feel included, they are more likely to bring their authentic selves to work and contribute to a positive and productive team dynamic.

Embracing diversity and inclusion in hiring practices not only helps organisations build stronger teams, but it also fosters a culture of fairness, equality, and respect. By actively seeking out candidates from underrepresented groups and creating inclusive hiring processes, organizations can make a significant impact in creating a more equitable society.

By embracing diversity and inclusion in your hiring practices, you not only improve your chances of finding the best candidate for the job, but you also create a more vibrant and successful organisation that thrives on the collective talents and unique perspectives of its employees.

Giving your current team a chance to grow and develop

While the search for the 'best candidate' can be enticing, it's essential not to overlook the potential and growth opportunities within your current team. Giving your current employees a chance to grow and develop not only benefits them individually but also contributes to the overall success of your organisation.

Investing in your current team members sends a powerful message of trust and value. By providing training, mentorship, and growth opportunities, you can tap into their untapped potential and help them reach new heights. Not only will this boost their confidence and job satisfaction, but it will also enhance their productivity and engagement in their work.

Moreover, nurturing the development of your current team members leads to increased loyalty and retention. When employees feel supported and recognised, they are more likely to stay with your organisation long-term, reducing turnover costs and maintaining continuity within your team.

Remember, success is not just about finding the 'best candidate' externally; it's about unlocking the potential of the individuals you already have. By giving your current team a chance to grow and develop, you can foster a culture of continuous improvement and create a strong foundation for long-term success.

Get In Touch


+44 (0) 203 761 5245

85 Tottenham Court Road,


+1 860 266 4825

2 Waterside Crossing,
Windsor, CT, 06095
United States